Casper vs Helix

Last Updated: May, 2024

Please Note: This Post Contains Affiliate Links

If you're searching for a bed-in-a-box mattress, Casper and Helix are perfect places to start. These are some of the most popular online brands, offering a wide variety of memory foam and hybrid mattresses with different features and merits. But how do these high-end mattresses compare?

In our Casper vs Helix Mattress review, we compare the Casper Original and the Helix Midnight in terms of their performance, materials, customers service, price, and more. We use our 2 stage review process to experience these mattresses and share our findings. By the end of this in-depth comparison, you should have a clear picture of which mattress between the two suits your sleeping position, comfort level, and budget. 

Casper vs Helix Mattress Comparison

Casper

Helix

Puffy Original
Casper
Helix

Mattress Models

Firmness Levels to Choose From

  • Medium firm rating 6.5
  • Medium firm rating 6.5

Highlights

  • Zoned support system for extra support around the lumbar region
  • Breathable Airscape foam allowing enhanced breathability
  • Great for back and side sleepers
  • Ideal for combination back and side sleepers
  • Great for couples due to motion isolation
  • High-Grade responsive foam keeps you buoyant and elevated

Sleep Trial

  • 100 night sleep trials
  • 100 night sleep trials
Casper Original Mattress

Casper is running a sale, active today May 23, 2024! 

With its perforated open cell foam top layer, this Casper makes a great choice for hot sleepers residing in hot regions or preparing for a summer month. Also, thanks to its zoned memory foam system it excels in motion isolation.

Mattress Construction & Performance

At the very top, is the thin knit soft breathable cover with multiple perforations that facilitate efficient airflow throughout the surface of the Casper Mattress. Underneath this cover is super soft and responsive layer that's ventilated and open-celled to shield hot sleepers against overheating and night sweats. Finally at the bottom is the support layer made of high-density memory foam. This polyfoam layer prevents the mattress from sagging and gives it the necessary support it needs.

Now that we have a glimpse at what this mattress is, let's see how it performs in different areas.

Casper Original Mattress Firmness

When I tested the mattress for firmness level, sitting on it felt softer. However, it felt pretty much like a firmer mattress upon lying down on it and rolling around. I rated its firmness level at a 6.5/10, which makes it a medium firm bed. 

Motion Isolation

Like any all-foam mattress, Casper Original lacks an innerspring and therefore has little to no bounce. When my partner and I tested it for motion isolation, the results exceeded our expectations. We could get in and out of bed without disturbing each other thanks to limited motion transfer from one side of the bed to the other. This makes the mattress a perfect fit for couples who often toss and turn in their sleep. 

Sleeping position

Although suited for all sleeping positions, it's majorly ideal for back and side sleepers. Combination sleepers also stand to benefit from this mattress but primarily those who often shift between their back and side. 

Pressure Relief 

Another thing I liked about this Original Casper Mattress is how it delivers exquisite pressure relief. It conforms closely to the body by redistributing your body weight which helps relieve pressure points. In addition, thanks to its tri-zone memory foam layer, I enjoyed extra support around my midsection which prevented my hips from sinking deeper into the surface.

Responsiveness

Compared to any typical all-foam mattress, the Casper Original Mattress is a bit more responsive. So moving across the surface is easy. For utmost reassurance, memory foam mattresses are reputable for responding to movements slowly but thanks to Casper's firmer foam layer at the base, changing sleep positions will be a walk in the park. Another layer that gives it its excellent responsiveness is the polyfoam zone at the top comfort layers. Compared to many ordinary foam beds, the polyfoam material on this memory foam mattress springs back to shape more quickly.

Edge Support

If you often sit or sleep near the mattress edge and feel like you're going to fall, then you'll know that edge support is an important factor. Despite being an all-foam bed, this Casper model grants you the freedom to spread across the entire mattress surface. For individuals with sleep partners solid edge support is super important as you need the entire surface of the mattress. Despite my 230-pound weight, I slept soundly near the edge of this Casper memory foam Mattress. Upon sitting on it, its high-density base foam ensured I felt excellently supported and secure. Note that like many all-foam mattresses out there, you need to limit your sitting on its edge as it might cause uneven premature sagging. Also, if your weight and that of your partner differs significantly, rotate the mattress 180 degrees after 3 - 6 months.

Durability and Weight limit

The original Casper Mattress doesn't have a weight limit. It's made to accommodate all types of sleepers. So, depending on how much you weigh, this mattress will feel like a softer or firmer mattress.

As for durability, all Casper mattresses are made of high-quality materials including this original model. So you can rest assured Casper Original will last a long time before buying a new mattress. As an average three-layer foam mattress, it should last around 7 years. If taken care of excellently, it can grant you a lifespan of 10 years. Aside from rotating it, remember to deep clean it at least once a year and keep it free of bad spills.

Safety Info

All foams used to make Casper Mattresses are CertiPUR-US Certified—meaning it doesn't have heavy metals and ozone depleters. This factor makes this Casper Original mattress ideal for sleepers who often deal with asthma or allergies.

Like with many mattress models, unboxing Casper Original releases an off-gassing. And based on my assessment, this off-gassing isn't harmful as it doesn't contain dangerous volatile organic compounds (VOCs). However, you're not supposed to use it immediately after unboxing it. We recommend keeping it in the open air for a day or two until the off-gassing fully dissipates.

Casper Mattress Price & Offers

Casper Original is one of Casper Bedding's entry-level memory foam mattresses. Notably, this mattress is Casper's second cheapest and an upper mid-range model in the market. The queen-size model of the Original Casper Mattress retails at $1,295. On average, you can get a 10% during Casper Sales. Twin size costs $895, Twin XL at $995, full at $1,195 while the King and the California King sizes go for $1,695. Though Casper mattress Sales aren't that frequent, you can be sure of spectacular discounts during their black Friday deals every year.

Service Satisfaction 

If you're looking to purchase Casper Original, it's available on Casper's official website. For those seeking an alternative place to purchase Casper mattresses, they can do so through Casper's Amazon.com page. Suppose you're seeking first-hand experience purchasing any Casper Mattress, they're also available in many brick-and-mortar stores. 

This Casper Memory Foam mattress comes with a 10-year warranty that covers structural and material defects. They include indentations larger than an inch, physical defects which cause the foam layers to crack prematurely and even zippers that aren't functioning properly. Defects the warranty doesn't cover include those caused by normal wear and tear and ones caused by improper handling of the mattress by the owner.

The company offers free shipping on their Casper mattresses including this model but only to buyers residing in the contiguous U.S. and provincial Canada. If you're living in Hawaii, Alaska, North Western region among other places, you'll have to pay for the delivery services.

Like many reputable mattress brands, Casper Original comes with a 100-night sleep trial. Before returning the mattress, you're advised to try it out for at least 30 days. 

Casper Bedding Company offers white glove delivery for their mattresses but at an additional fee to individuals in the continental United States, and select cities in Canada. The white glove service involves removing your old mattress and replacing it with the new Casper Mattress. In addition, assembly of the entire structure will be done to your liking.

Helix Midnight

Helix Midnight

Thanks to its medium-firm feel this helix midnight mattress suits quite many different types of sleepers. In the motion isolation department, it does remarkably well making it ideal for couples. 

Mattress construction & Performance

This helix hybrid mattress comes wrapped in a soft breathable knit cover. The cover is also stretchy which helps promote further cooling. Immediately underneath the stretchy cover is the comfort layer. This layer's composition includes high-grade Helix Responsive Foam and Memory Plus Foam. The Helix helix-responsive foam acts as the mattress' transition layer that prevents sleepers from bottoming out on this Hybrid Mattress. On the other hand, Memory Plus Foam—Helix's proprietary memory foam—has a slow-moving feel. Aside from providing nice contouring, this blend of memory foam layers helps relieve pressure at the joints. Like most hybrid mattresses, this helix midnight model has about 1,000 individually wrapped coils that hold its support layer together. Spaces within the innerspring coils help promote efficient airflow and overall breathability while also adding support to the overall structure. 

Helix Midnight Mattress Firmness

As previously stated, mattress firmness is a subjective metric and therefore depends on the sleeper's experience of using the mattress. After testing this Helix Midnight Mattress for its firmness, I rated it 6.5/10, meaning this Helix Mattress is a medium firm mattress.

Motion Isolation

When it comes to limiting motion transfer across the mattress, memory foam models excel in this area. But the helix midnight mattress is unique in that its performance on motion isolation almost matches that of memory foam beds. When my partner and I tested this hybrid mattress, we noticed that we got in and out of the bed without disturbing each other. Also tossing and turning didn't interfere with anyone's sleep. 

We conducted further tests by placing a glass of water on top of the mattress and then dropped a 20-pound steel ball on either side of the bed to see how much the water in the glass moved. As expected the water barely moved. This feature makes this hybrid mattress a great choice for couples who toss and turn more often in their sleep. 

Sleeping Position 

Helix beds are made to comfortably accommodate all types of sleepers including this Helix Mattress. As a lightweight sleeper, I enjoyed the excellent contouring and support this mattress provided me. Average-weight side sleepers may experience some form of discomfort sleeping on this mattress but generally, this is no cause for alarm.

When I rolled on my back, I experienced a sinkage that was sufficient to offer excellent cushioning around my curves without sacrificing too much support. Generally, I liked how the foams felt. It was soft but not too soft which didn't make me feel like I was stuck on the surface. Heavyweight back sleepers weighing more than 230 pounds will sink a bit deeper but they'll enjoy the top-notch blend of cushioning in conjunction with excellent support. Lightweight back sleepers should experience the incredible comfort this helix mattress has to offer.

As for stomach sleeping, I felt a decent amount of cushioning, contouring, and support. But after some time I started feeling some strain on my back. I wouldn't recommend this helix mattress to exclusive stomach sleepers weighing more than 200 pounds as they risk developing back aches as a result of spinal misalignment. However lightweight stomach sleepers weighing less than 150 pounds should experience the mattress’ incredible blend of comfort and support.

Pressure Relief 

Thanks to its polyfoam and memory foam layers this Helix Mattress does well in delivering excellent pressure relief. These foam layers allow you to sink just enough into the sleep surface for deep cradling. This helps relieve pressure from the shoulders and hips. Side sleepers looking for an effectively pressure-relieving mattress should consider going for this mattress. 

Responsiveness

As a combination sleeper who often shifts from side to back sleeping and vice versa, I found the responsiveness of this mattress to be spectacular. Switching sleeping positions was relatively effortless since the mattress quickly adapted to the changes in my movements. So for combination sleepers seeking an incredibly responsive bed, Helix Midnight Mattress is their go-to choice.

Edge Support

Helix Midnight Mattress has good edge support but according to me, I'd put its sturdiness at a slightly above average. When I sat on it for the first few minutes, it felt sturdier until it started getting less supportive. I think those who stand to gain significantly from sitting and sleeping on this mattress' edge are individuals weighing 180 pounds and below.

Durability and Weight Limit

On the durability department, Helix Midnight being a hybrid mattress should give you a decent 7 to 8 years of comfort. With proper care, you can expect a lifespan of up to 10 years or more.

Helix Midnight Mattress has a 1000-pound weight limit for the queen-size model. That means 500 pounds on each side. Overall, this is a great mattress that supports all body types, sizes, and shapes.

Safety Info

Another thing I liked about this Helix Mattress is that it hardly released any odor. In fact, as we waited for it to fully expand we didn't experience any form of wheezing. However, it's advisable to leave it out in the open air or room with proper ventilation for any trace of odor to dissipate completely.

Like any other Hybrid mattress with memory foam construction, foams used on this bed are CertiPUR-US Certified. This means the foams have undergone a rigorous test for emission, durability, and performance and therefore safe for use. If you have asthma or allergies, this mattress is worth considering as it doesn't emit any harmful VOCs.

Casper Mattress Price & Offers 

Helix Midnight Mattress is available at affordable prices across all sizes. While other mattress brands keep raising their prices, Helix Sleep Bedding company actually lowered their price in 2023. 

If you are hunting for the perfect opportunity to get incredible discounts, the company offers 20-25% off on major sales events. For a high-quality hybrid mattress, the queen-size Helix Midnight model's price fell to $999 in 2023. Remember, purchasing this mattress comes with a pair of free pillows. 

Generally, twin, twin XL, and full size cost $936, $1,061, and $1,248 respectively. The Queen Size costs $1,373 while the King and California King models each cost $1,748. Periods to expect major Helix Sleep sales events are; Labor Day, Black Friday deals, Independence Day, Memorial Day, and President's Day.

Service Satisfaction

Helix Mattresses come with great trials and warranties. For instance, the Midnight model comes with a 100-night risk-free trial like the Casper Mattress, it's best to test Helix Midnight for at least 30 days before deciding on whether or not it meets your comfort needs. 

With a generous 10-year warranty, you can rest assured that this mattress will grant comfort for quite a long time. The warranty covers defects such as tears in the fabric, persistent indentations that won't go away, and sagging. Keep in mind that the warranty will only cover sagging issues so long as you use the recommended bed base. Like Casper's, Helix's warranty won't cover damages caused by improper handling of the mattress or the use of the wrong bed base.

Like most online mattress brands, Helix uses the 'bed in a box' method for shipping their mattresses. All Helix Mattresses are manufactured in the U.S. and ship for free anywhere in the United States.

Casper vs Helix 

Product Name

Firmness

Sleeping Positon

Warranty

Queen Price

Casper Original

6.5/10

Back Sleepers
Side Sleepers
Combination Sleepers

10 Years

$1295

Helix
MidNight

6.5/10

Couples
Back Sleepers
Side Sleepers

10 Years

$1373

Casper vs Helix: Which Mattress is Best for You?

Everyone has different mattress needs.  There's no one mattress perfect for all. It all comes down to certain factors, such as;

  • Your sleeping position
  • Your body weight
  • Whether you sleep hot/cold
  • Health issues e.g. allergies, sciatica, and others

Other factors that can influence your mattress experience include your type of bed base and pillow. If you’ve had a medical procedure recently done, you may require an entirely different type of mattress, from what you’d normally get. You have to consider all these while choosing between the Casper Original and the Helix Midnight Mattress. 

Other Casper Models to Consider

While the original Casper is a magnificent choice, it’s not the best for everyone. If you prefer a hybrid version you can choose the Original Hybrid or the Casper Wave Hybrid. If you’re searching for a more affordable option, The Casper might be for you. Let us briefly see what they offer.

Casper Original Hybrid

Casper Original Hybrid

If you're searching for a bouncy and supportive mattress, the Casper Original Hybrid is the mattress for you. While it has a buoyant feel, it still relieves painful pressure points, making it a great pick for back and combination sleepers. 

Casper Original Hybrid's Best Performance 

  • The Casper Original Hybrid boasts a faster response time that improves ease of movement, prevents the “stuck” feeling and enhances sex, making it a great choice for active couples. 
  • This mattress boasts excellent lying edge support and exceptionally good sitting edge support, thanks to its 3.5-inch perimeter edge support foam. 
  • The Casper Original Hybrid's comfort layer does an excellent task of alleviating painful pressure points and keeping sleepers comfortable. 
  • The unique design of this hybrid mattress combines memory foam, pocketed coils, and polyfoam, creating a sleep surface with a medium-firm feel that appeals to a wide range of sleepers. 
  • The Original Hybrid features a relatively thin comfort layer, which creates plenty of breathability and airflow.
  • The top foam layers of the Original Hybrid are soft which enables them to fill in the space around the lower back as the bouncy pocketed coils lift the hip region in line with the shoulders. 

Casper Wave Hybrid

Casper Wave Hybrid

Tired of having sleepless nights due to chronic back pain? You may want to check out the Casper Wave Hybrid. It does an excellent task of combining softness and overall body support, striking a perfect balance between lift and pressure relief. 

Casper Wave Hybrid's Best Performance 

  • The Casper Wave Hybrid's unique construction sets the spine in a neutral line, while actively alleviating tension around the hips, shoulders, and lower back.
  • This hybrid mattress has some excellent mobility, making it easy for combination sleepers to move around and change sleep positions at night.
  • The Casper Wave Hybrid is supportive enough to keep the spine of heavyweight sleepers aligned, yet soft enough to offer plenty of relief around their joints.
  • The Casper Original Hybrid features a Zoned Support Max layer that offers ample pressure relief at the shoulders, while cradling the hips and lower back for spinal alignment.
  • This mattress has several high-quality cooling features to regulate body temperature.
  • The Casper Original Hybrid's medium-firm feel makes it an ideal pick for lightweight and average-weight side and back sleepers.

The Casper

The Casper

The Casper features cooling technology, pressure-relieving foam layers, and a sturdy support system, all at an affordable price tag. All its foam layers are CertiPUR-US certified and made without ozone-depleting chemicals, making it a good choice for sensitive sleepers.

The Casper's Best Performance 

  • The Casper features a Casper Signature Foam layer with AirScape Technology to increase airflow and soothe you to slumber land. 
  • This mattress boasts a premium memory foam layer conforms to the sleeper's body to absorb pressure. 
  • The ProSupport Foam layer in the Casper promotes proper spinal alignment and keeps the mattress from sinking and sagging. 
  • In addition to being easy to move around, the Casper does an excellent task of positioning the spine in an even line, making it a great pick for back sleeping. 
  • The Casper boasts a softer feel around the shoulder, which makes it a perfect alternative for sleepers trying to avoid shoulder pain. 
  • This mattress is also a great choice for sleepers struggling with back pain. It strikes a perfect balance between overall body support and pressure relief.

Other Helix Models to Choose from

If the Helix original memory foam mattress doesn’t seem like your cup of tea, we have other great options for you. For comfort upgrade and better support, choose the Midnight Luxe. For back and side sleepers, consider the Helix Moonlight or the Helix Dusk.

Midnight Luxe

Midnight Luxe

As a luxury cooling model of the Original Helix Midnight bed, the Midnight Luxe works for hot sleepers of all body types and sleep positions. 

Midnight Luxe's Best Performance

  • The Helix Midnight Luxe is firm and supportive enough for average-weight and lightweight stomach sleepers.
  • The Midnight Luxe has tons of breathable layers, pocketed coils, and a TENCEL cover to keep sleepers temperature-neutral at night.
  • The coils in the Midnight Luxe make it bouncy and easy for combination sleepers and couples to change positions on.
  • This mattress features a zoned support system designed to offer support where you need it the most.
  • The hybrid construction of the Midnight Luxe offers exceptional zoned lumbar support, making it a great option for sleepers with back pain.
  • The Midnight Luxe features a polyfoam transition layer that contours to the unique shape of the body and cradles around the shoulders and midsection of side sleepers. 

Helix Dusk

Helix Dusk

If you're a back sleeper who prefers a little extra cushioning, the Helix Dusk might be the mattress for you. Its soft top layer cradles the body, while the coil system and the medium-firm feel offers the body support needed for spinal alignment. 

Helix Dusk's Best Performance

  • The Helix Dusk's proprietary foam cradle the body curves around the leg, hips, shoulders, and neck for ergonomic support.
  • The dense, pocketed coil layer in the Helix Dusk offers buoyant support, allowing sleepers to easily change positions without feeling stuck in.
  • In addition to stabilizing edge support and increasing sleep area, the reinforced perimeters of the Helix Dusk make it perfect for kids, couples, and the elderly prone to falling.
  • The Helix Dusk is firm enough to support the shoulders and midsection of back sleepers irrespective of their body type.
  • The Helix Dusk uses the Helix Soft Touch Design optimized to keep the surface cool.
  • This bed has a responsive foam layer and a coil support system that give it a firm, bouncy feel. 

Helix Moonlight

Helix Moonlight

The Helix Moonlight is a perfect fit for side sleeping thanks to its soft and breathable feel. Those who suffer from hip pain should also love how this bed’s super soft layers cradle and cushion painful pressure points. 

Helix Moonlight's Best Performance

  • The Helix Dusk's proprietary foam cradle the body curves around the leg, hips, shoulders, and neck for ergonomic support.
  • The dense, pocketed coil layer in the Helix Dusk offers buoyant support, allowing sleepers to easily change positions without feeling stuck in.
  • In addition to stabilizing edge support and increasing sleep area, the reinforced perimeters of the Helix Dusk make it perfect for kids, couples, and the elderly prone to falling.
  • The Helix Dusk is firm enough to support the shoulders and midsection of back sleepers irrespective of their body type.
  • The Helix Dusk uses the Helix Soft Touch Design optimized to keep the surface cool.
  • This bed has a responsive foam layer and a coil support system that give it a firm, bouncy feel. 

Closing Thoughts 

Both Casper and Helix are reputable bed-in-a-box mattress brands well-known for their excellent customer service and durable products. However, they have different merits and demerits that may appeal to different sleepers. The Casper Original, for instance, has an all-foam construction that relieves painful pressure points and offers excellent motion isolation, making it a solid pick for couples, side sleepers, and individuals with joint pain. 

The Helix Midnight, on the other hand, boasts a hybrid design that gives it a perfect balance of support and conforming, not to mention better edge support and temperature regulation than Casper. This makes it a great choice for hot sleepers, back sleepers, and individuals who crave a durable and more supportive sleep surface. Overall, by considering your sleeping needs, personal preferences, and budget, you can rest assured of finding a Helix or Casper Mattress of your dreams.

Posted in: VS

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *