Finding The Best Pillow Top Mattress

Last Updated: October, 2022

Please Note: This Post Contains Affiliate Links

When you go to sleep, it’s about getting a full night of rest. It doesn’t feel like there’s much of a point to sleeping if you don’t really feel comfortable on your mattress after all.

That’s where your pillow top mattress comes in. With the best best pillow top mattress, you can get a good night’s sleep, but take a look to learn more about which one will work for your specifications. Firm or soft: whatever your preference, you can find the best pillow top mattress to make your sleep restful. If you're curious you can learn more about what a pillow top mattress is here.

Our Picks For The Best Pillow Top Mattresses

SweetNight Twilight - Small

Twilight - Sweetnight Hybrid Mattress

The Sweetnight is a healthy pillow top mattress—yes, healthy! It includes the support and a buffer to help your back so that you’re ready to go when you wake up. This bed is also ultra, affordable, starting at just $378.

Sealy Response Premium Euro Pillow Top Mattress

Sealy Response Premium Euro Pillow Top Mattress

Comfortable, and with protection from moisture throughout the night too. That’s the Sealy Response, which you can relax in without a problem.

Suiforlun Hybrid Pillowtop Mattress

Suiforlun Hybrid Pillowtop Mattress

Support and comfort: that’s basically all you need to sleep well at night. It’s great that this, and coolness, motion isolation, and firmness, is what the Suiforlun is all about.

Zinus Ultima Comfort Mattress

Zinus Ultima Comfort Pillow Top Mattress

You’ll feel the firm mattress support of the Zinus as soon as you lie down. It’s perfect for motion transfer, with springs that will keep your back feeling great.

Classic Brands Graymercy Euro Top

Classic Brands Graymercy Euro Top

There’s a reason why Graymercy is a classic brand: this mattress is supported, with high-quality foam, and perfect for allergies too.

DreamFoam Bedding Doze

DreamFoam Bedding Doze

The zoned comfort of this DreamFoam option is great for anyone, and perfect for people who like different levels of firmness at night.

Modway Jenna

Modway Jenna

Sleep on the Modway Jenna for a supportive mattress, responsive foam, and a smooth and even feel right on top.

SweetNight Twilight

What We Like

  • Offers plenty of edge support
  • Supports pressure points for people of all weights
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Starts at just $378
  • Free shipping & returns
  • 10 year warranty

What We Don't Like

  • This hybrid mattress is very heavy and hard to carry for one person

Overall Thoughts: 

If you have a partner at home, or even an excitable dog that sleeps with you, this Sweetnight Queen is a great option for you. That’s because it includes motion isolation, so when one person gets out of bed, the other won’t feel a lot of moving.


Lie down to feel that comfort underneath your back thanks to the 775 individually wrapped pocketed coils with memory foam. This medium-firm hybrid mattress is great for pressure relief, back pain, and the usual tossing and turning people do at night. Rest all night on the three independent zones of the bed. They will absorb your body weight evenly for the whole night.


When it comes to value, this mattress is incredible. While it's a very high quality mattress (SweetNight's most popular model) it starts at only $378. Use code SLEEPSHOP at checkout to get the best pillow top mattress discount available.

Sealy Response Premium Euro Pillow Top Mattress

Sealy Response Premium Euro Pillow Top Mattress

What We Like

  • Great in terms of firmness
  • Meant to hold its shape
  • Ideal for hot sleepers as it doesn't feel hot at all when you sleep

What We Don't Like

  • Can become lopsided over time

Overall Thoughts: 

If you've been on the hunt for the best pillow top mattresses in the market, the Sealy Response Premium Euro Pillow Top Mattress is a solid option. Sealy is a well-known brand, and with good reason. This best pillow top mattress is plush, with a 2-inch extra soft cushion on top, and coils inside that are meant to provide you with more targeted support. This also means that there’s no motion transfer when someone gets up off the bed.

 
Relax atop the Posturepedic technology, which will deliver support to where you need it most, and sink into the high-quality foam that provides flexible and durable support. Okay, not actually sinking, but you’ll feel the soft feeling. You can relax knowing that this mattress is designed to keep hot sleepers cool through the night too, making it one of the best euro top mattresses out there in its price range.

Not Rea​​​​dy To Buy Today?

That's okay! Sign up for our newsletter to get access to the best mattress deals available online. 

This list is ONLY for deals we negotiate for our readers. No spam. Ever

Suiforlun Hybrid Pillowtop Mattress

Suiforlun Hybrid Pillowtop Mattress

What We Like

  • Does not sag over time and maintains good edge support
  • Supports people of varying body weights
  • The bed itself is easy to unpack and set up

What We Don't Like

  • This memory foam mattress is very soft; not for firmer sleepers

Overall Thoughts: 

You’ll sigh in relief when you lie back on this Suiforlun Hybrid mattress. The innerspring mattress will support your body while the gel memory foam mattresses conform to you for a good night’s sleep. Those individually-wrapped pocketed coils isolate any motion on the bed, but beyond those, know that the gel layer on top of this hybrid bed will help keep you cool throughout the night. All you have to do is lie down.

Need Help Sleeping Better? Request our FREE Sleep Hygiene Guide.

  • Understand Your Sleep Habits
  • Identify The Effects of Poor Sleep
  • Causes Of Difficulty Sleeping
  • Step By Step Guide
  • 5 Tips To Improve Your Sleep
  • Frequently Asked Questions
Zinus Ultima Comfort Mattress

What We Like

  • Comfortable when you first lie down
  • The springs are very supportive
  • The memory foam is quite soft
  • Exceptional pressure relief

What We Don't Like

  • The mattress is not as durable over time

Overall Thoughts: 

If you’re looking for a firm option, look no further than Zinus. It’s meant to provide customized support to help all the pressure in our back—on account of the comfort memory foam and iCoil Pocketed Springs. These springs are all independent, which means that they’ll eliminate any motion transfer if someone happens to get up during the night. Thanks to the high-quality foam too, the mattress should keep its shape and stay durable over time.


>> Related Content: Best Extra Firm Mattress

Classic Brands Graymercy Euro Top

Classic Brands Graymercy Euro Top

What We Like

  • It’s soft, but there’s still firmness to it
  • Only takes a few minutes to unbox it
  • Right in between plush and medium-firm

What We Don't Like

  • There are some issues with the mattress expanding properly

Overall Thoughts: 

Graymercy is a unique brand for plush pillow top mattresses, since they combine the support of a wrapped coil system inside with the conforming response of gel-infused memory foam right on top. The gel memory foam layers will draw heat away from you at night. This way, you can sleep comfortably.


At the same time, those springs will prevent you from waking up when someone else leaves the bed. These pillow tops are hypoallergenic, too, meaning that they're completely resistant to all allergens, mold, and bacteria and perfect for those of you with allergies.

DreamFoam Bedding Doze

DreamFoam Bedding Doze

What We Like

  • Very soft and comfortable
  • It expands quickly and doesn’t smell like chemicals
  • Great for a medium-firm feeling

What We Don't Like

  • The sidewalls are not very firm and supported

Overall Thoughts: 

We all sleep differently, which is why you might want to take a serious look at this luxury hybrid mattress, which is built with three different levels of thickness. It offers lots of support for different levels of comfort to keep you feeling great in the areas where your body needs it the most. You might need to wait a moment for the mattress to expand. But when it does, you’ll be able to sleep and enjoy the mattress topper comfortably.

Modway Jenna

Modway Jenna

What We Like

  • Great for handling back pain
  • It’s a firm pillow top and has plenty of support
  • Not squeaky or noisy

What We Don't Like

  • Tends to sink a little over time

Overall Thoughts: 

Sleep soundly on the Modway Jenna, which is made to offer pressure relief on your hips, back, shoulders, and neck, so no matter where your pain areas are, you’ll feel supported. Those individually-wrapped pocketed coils will isolate motion so that you can sleep even when your partner gets up. It’s great that setup is easy too, so all you have to do is unbox and unwrap it before you’ll be ready to sleep on it.

Getting to Know Pillow Top Beds

The pillow top mattress is a type of luxury mattress, or so they’re advertised as. Really, they’re just as the name suggests: a mattress with an extra top layer of padding. This padding might be made from polyfoam, memory foam, natural latex, or more commonly now, gel. Basically, these are your normal quality mattresses but with more comfort and contouring to help you rest easy.

These pillow top mattresses are also made with an innerspring mattress construction, meaning that they have a lot of support underneath the top layer of padding. The whole point of getting a pillow top is to blend comfort and support all into one, so you get a plush pillow sleeping sensation while feeling support where you need it most.

Features to Keep in Mind

Purchasing a new mattress can be pretty confusing. There's a wide range of options on the market, and companies often use fancy marketing terms that can make it challenging to understand how a bed actually performs.

Before you make your purchase, let’s take a look at what you should think about when choosing your mattress. They may all look similar, but they don’t sleep the same.

Budget

Of course, consider the price. Generally, pillow top mattresses aren’t terribly expensive anyway, at least compared to other options, but check out to see what the price between pillow top mattresses are and how that impacts the materials that are used.

Pillow top innerspring mattresses are often considered cheap alternatives compared to hybrid beds. This makes them an attractive option for sleepers who need pressure relief on a budget. Because of their high-quality materials and more sophisticated construction, euro-top beds will set you back more.

Materials

Speaking of materials, this should be one of the first things you look at. Check to be sure that you’re buying something that’s made of high-quality memory foam that won’t sink over time. You can even check for a gel option that will help you sleep more easily, but either way, your choice should be comfortable and durable. You can choose between foam, natural latex, innerspring mattresses with organic cotton construction, and more.

Firmness

People sleep with different preferences, so consider whether you like a firmer or plush pillow top mattress before making a purchase decision. Pillow tops are usually a little softer thanks to the actual pillow top, but there is still a lot of support built into the design. That’s due to the innersprings that work on the parts of your back that you need help on.

Temperature Regulation

Temperature regulation with pillow top beds depends on the construction and materials of your mattress. For instance, memory foam pillow tops can easily get uncomfortably warm, especially in closely conforming mattresses, leaving no room for heat to escape. Latex and cotton pillow tops, on the other hand, can form a barrier between you and the rest of the bed, preventing heat retention and allowing room for airflow. 

Conforming Abilities

Pillow tops usually add plushness to otherwise firm sleep surfaces. However, they can't replace the deep cradle of memory foam mattresses. So, if you're a type of sleeper who wants deep body contouring and pressure relief, you might find that pillow tops won't offer the needed "hug" to align your spine and relieve pressure points.

Warranty

When it comes to buying a mattress, it’s never a bad idea to think about the warranty. A lot of brands offer 10 years, while some go as far as 25 years. Most people tend to use their pillow top mattresses for 10 years total, so think about if that’s something important to you and how long you think you can go before you need to buy a new mattress.

Some Luxury

A pillow top mattress is great for a little bit of a luxury firm feel in your bedroom. If this is something you want, there’s no better option than a pillow top. They’re comfortable and provide a little more visual appeal to your bedroom too. Check the design to see if it will fit in your décor.

Sleep Trial Period

Pillow top beds offer immediate cushioning that performs well in showrooms, giving the sleep surface a luxurious, inviting, and comfy feel when you first lie on it. However, it's wise to choose a pillow top mattress with a generous trial period and use it for at least 30 days to see how it holds up. This will give you a good idea of whether the bed will be supportive and comfortable enough in the long run. 

Durability

Generally, the materials used in designing a pillow top mattress are less durable than those in other mattresses. For instance, fiberfill, memory foam, and similar models can develop permanent indentations after a few years of use, which unfortunately shortens your bed's lifespan as a whole. That said, for a more robust and long-lasting choice, consider pillow tops designed with high-density memory foam or latex. 

Advantages and Disadvantages of a Pillow Top Mattress

Advantages

Why get a pillow top? Or maybe the real question for you is why shouldn’t you get one. Either way, there are reasons to buy and not to buy a pillow top. Let’s start with the advantages.

Low Price

Yes, price indeed matters. It’s good to know then that a pillow top mattress is made to be soft and supportive without being overly expensive. A pillow top is just a single top layer of padding added to your mattress after all, which means that it won’t cost you as much as adding in an entire top layer of foam on your own. Luxury and at a good price.

Motion Isolation

The springs in pillow top mattresses are isolated, meaning that when one person gets up, the other person won’t feel the vibrations. It helps that there’s that layer of foam or gel on top that stops the motion of the bed.

Great For All Sleepers

One of the best things about pillow top mattresses is that different types of sleepers can find comfort in many different sleeping positions. Average-weight stomach sleepers or side sleepers will be able to relax since these types of mattresses comfort and support your body.

Pain Relief

With the added softness on top of this firm style of mattress, you’ll get a support that is made to conform to your body and therefore provide you with better pain relief. Side sleepers especially feel this relief, since the spine won’t align as easily in this position.
Sadly, a pillow top mattress won’t help with all problems. Chronic back pain might not improve, and you might want to add something orthopedic to help further.

Responsiveness

Latex pillow tops can give your bed a more responsive surface suitable for active couples and makes it easier to change sleeping positions.

Disadvantages

Before purchasing a new mattress, you also need to know the disadvantages that come with it. There are so many great things about a pillow top mattress, so why might you want to reconsider? Take a look at the possible disadvantages.

Heat

Depending on the type of foam the pillow top mattress uses, you may notice that it’s hotter. More recent gel options have attempted to combat this, but some foams will keep foam contained while hot sleepers sleep, which means they'll be a little warm at night.

Indentations

It’s definitely possible that your pillow top will indent over time, especially if it’s made from cheaper materials. Try to get pillow tops that have a more high-end memory foam option in this case, which can offer you more back and spinal support but at a higher price.

Deep-Pocket Sheets

Virtually all pillow tops come with a higher-than-average profile that may need deep-pocket sheets. So, this means investing in new bedding along with your new mattress.

Conclusion

There’s a lot that goes into buying your mattress, and into buying a pillow top. Pillow tops are comfortable, supportive, and look great. So if you can overlook a few possible disadvantages, you might want to consider adding one to your bedroom. Finding the right one will help you sleep well and hopefully fix some back problems—just make sure that you consider which one will work best for you from our pillow top mattress reviews.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.