Sealy Mattress Complaints

With an established reputation spanning 100 years plus, time and again, Sealy has had the resilience to adapt to new trends by producing quality products aligning with consumers' preferences. Though their mattresses are designed to deliver a perfect balance of comfort and support, some buyers don't feel like these mattresses rise to the occasion. For that reason, many previous buyers have complained of some of their mattress models dipping at the center, making noise, and false warranty claims, among others.

In this article, we'll dive deeper into the most common complaints about Sealy mattresses. We'll also state possible solutions alongside viable alternative mattresses, based on our 2-stage review process, to help upgrade your sleep experience.

Sealy Posturepedic Mattress Makes Noise

A Sealy Posturepedic Mattress buyer complained of his mattress making noise. He bought the mattress and a compatible box spring to help boost overall sleep comfort. However, he claimed that a couple of months into using the Posturepedic Mattress, it started squeaking when he was getting in and out of bed and even at night when he tossed and turned on the surface. Surprisingly, there wasn't any depression on the mattress.

The posturepedic technology the company uses on their posturepedic mattresses ensures the mattress doesn't make noise. The noise might be coming from the box spring. Replacing this model with a new mattress might not solve the problem if the squeaking originates from the foundation. Another possibility could be friction between the encased coil system and the surrounding materials, like memory foam. This is common in most Posturepedic mattresses. Always ensure you maintain your Sealy Mattress properly as directed by the manufacturer and pair it with a proper bed frame or foundation. You can also place a mattress pad between the bed frame and the mattress to act as a buffer. If the squeaking is coming from the mattress' encased coils, then a favourable replacement would be the Cocoon by Sealy.

If none of these solutions work for you, and you want a mattress from an entirely different brand, then consider replacing the Posturepedic Mattress with the Nolah Signature 12” Mattress.

Nolah Signature 12” Mattress

Priced at $1,169 for the queen-size model, the Nolah Signature Mattress is a perfect alternative to the Sealy Posturepedic Mattress. If you're an eco-conscious sleeper, this memory foam mattress comes with GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US® certification, assuring you hygienic slumber all night long. This makes the mattress a perfect fit for individuals with asthma or allergies.

As one of the best memory foam mattresses on the market, Nolah Signature 12” features 7-inch high-density foam at its support layer that provides great lumbar support for back sleepers and edge support for occasional sitting. It also features plush contouring AirFoam and a highly resilient supportive foam in its comfort layer, which makes the mattress super responsive. More importantly, these foam layers don't make any noise, so you can rest assured of a good night's sleep. Other mattress features that make this mattress worth seeking include a 100% organic cotton cover and the proprietary Nolah AirFoam, which keeps hot sleepers cool during hot nights. 

Nolah Signature 12” bed comes with a 120-night sleep trial period to help you decide if its features meet your comfort preferences. The company also offers a lifetime warranty to ensure the mattress maintains maximum comfort your entire life. Shipping is also free to shoppers who reside within the continental United States.

Sealy Mattress Causes Back Pain

Seven months into using the Sealy Mattress, a customer complained of experiencing back pain over time. This kind of dissatisfaction has made rounds on several social media platforms, and it has become an essential concern in the mattress industry for the Sealy company. 

A possible cause of the back pain by the Sealy Mattress could be a result of lack of proper support for healthy spinal alignment. Though Sealy mattresses are popular for providing plush comfort,  they may not offer the needed support for maintaining neutral spinal alignment. If you're suffering from back pains, you should be aware of your sleeping position. Back sleepers can alleviate back pains by placing a pillow under the knees for additional lumbar support. On the other hand, side sleepers can place a pillow between their knees to keep their spine aligned with the neck and the head.

If you're looking for the best mattress for back pain, a perfect alternative to your current defective mattress would be the PlushBeds Botanical Bliss. 

PlushBeds Organic Latex - Botanical Bliss Mattress

Like most high end mattresses, such as the Tempur pedic, this bed doesn't come cheaply. Though usually priced at $2,900 for the queen-size model, PlushBeds offers, and discounts can get you this mattress for half the normal price. As a high-quality mattress, this bed is made of 100% British Organic wool, Talalay, and Sri Lankan Botanical latex. Individuals seeking an eco-friendly bed will be glad to know that this latex mattress is also GOTS and  OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified. 

The Botanical Bliss from PlushBeds features the Dunlop Latex, which acts as a transition zone between the bottom Dunlop latex and the top Talalay latex. So, average-weight back sleepers weighing 130-230 pounds stand to gain from this mattress as it will grant them an incredible balance of comfort and support. Average-weight side sleepers are better off seeking other mattresses that are a bit softer than this model. If you fall into this category, the PlushBeds Botanical Bliss may not grant you the necessary body contouring comfort and cushioning for a rejuvenating slumber. The Botanical Bliss Mattress also makes an incredible pick for hot sleepers. With its advanced cooling technology, this mattress not only helps keep you cool but also shields you against night sweats. 

The mattress comes with a 100-night sleep trial, free shipping within the contiguous U.S. and a 25-year prorated warranty. The company also offers White Glove delivery to buyers residing within the contiguous U.S. This involves assembling your mattress and replacing your old mattress with the new one—all at a flat rate of $299. 

Sealy Mattress Sinks in the Middle

Another Sealy Posturepedic Mattress buyer complained about his mattress sinking and dipping in the middle. They claim they had been rotating their sleep positions on different areas of the mattress surface to prevent it from dipping, but it happened anyway. They also claim to have paired the Posturepedic Mattress with a bed frame. 

One possible cause of the dipping at the center of the mattress is putting weight in the middle of the mattress. Notably, your body weight is majorly concentrated at the hips. If you're a heavyweight sleeper and you opt for a medium or medium firm mattress, it's likely to sink in the middle relatively quickly. You want to ensure you choose a mattress suitable for your sleep position and body weight. 

If you'd like an alternative instead of switching the Sealy bed for a brand-new mattress from the same company, the Bear Elite Hybrid is your go-to option. 

Bear Elite Hybrid Mattress

The hybrid version of this Bear mattress is available in 3 models: soft, firm, and medium firm. For just $1,500, you can bet that acquiring the queen-size model of this mattress will be worth every penny. Unlike other mattresses that come with a strong “new mattress” smell, this Bear Hybrid Mattress doesn't have an unpleasant off-gassing smell. This is thanks to its CertiPurUS and GREENGUARD Gold certification, which show it's free of harmful emissions and toxins.

Since you're seeking a bed that won't dip easily, the extra-firm hybrid version of this mattress is the ideal choice. In addition to the 14 inch thickness, the encased coils system and other features making this mattress firm should be sufficient to prevent any potential dipping at the center. The encased coils at the support layer make it super responsive and easy to move around on the surface. If edge support is also something you're after, the reinforced coils around its edges make it convenient for occasional sitting. You can also comfortably sleep near the bed's perimeter without worrying about rolling off your mattress at night. Bear Elite Hybrid rates at around 6-7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. This firmness level is ideal for sleepers needing a firmer mattress surface that offers a gentle cradle while hugging the body. Hip and back pain sufferers should also find the pressure-relieving comfort they need from the Bear Elite Hybrid. 

Backed by a lifetime warranty, you can rest assured you'll have prolonged sleep comfort with this hybrid mattress. What's more, it comes with a 120-night sleep trial, and it ships for free throughout the continental United States.

False Warranty Claim

Some customers have complained about the Sealy Mattress company having false warranty claims. For instance, a buyer claimed that two years into using the Sealy mattress, it had started causing him sleep discomfort. He stated that he had rotated the mattress periodically to prevent the dipping, which is common for causing body aches, with no success. Despite the company offering a 10-year limited warranty on this mattress, the client stated that the terms and conditions in the coverage don't justify claims. For instance, while the company considers a 30-35mm sag normal, the width of the mattress makes it seem rather large and capable of causing body pains. 

If you're seeking an alternative brand-new mattress for your Cocoon Mattress by Sealy with reliable warranty policies, go for the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid.

If you're seeking an alternative brand-new mattress for your Cocoon Mattress by Sealy with reliable warranty policies, go for the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress

As one of the best and most affordable beds in the mattress industry, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid only costs $1,249 for the queen-size model. This mattress’ foams are CertiPUR-US certified, meaning this mattress is free of harmful ozone depleters—making it fit for asthmatic and individuals with allergies.

Similar to what Sealy offers, this Brooklyn Bedding Mattress comes with a 10-year warranty. The warranty covers indentations that are at least an inch deep. It also covers splitting or cracking of the Titan flex foam or other layers. With the warranty, the company will repair your mattress or exchange it with a new one in case of any deterioration like crumbling. Sagging is also included in the warranty as long as you use the recommended foundation by the manufacturer.

Aside from the 10-year warranty, this Brooklyn Mattress comes with a 120-night sleep trial and free shipping via FedEx to shoppers residing in the continental United States.

Sealy Posturepedic Mattress isn't Supportive Enough for Heavyweight Sleepers

Some customers have voiced dissatisfaction with Sealy mattresses, claiming it doesn't provide enough support for heavyweight individuals. A possible cause of this is opting for a mattress that's too soft and unfit for your body size. With a rating of about 5.5/10 on the firmness scale, this Posturepedic Mattress is majorly ideal for lightweight individuals, including stomach and back sleepers. So, if you are in this category, you'll be better off with a medium to medium-firm model that can offer the support you need. 

An incredible option you can never go wrong with is the Nolah Evolution Comfort Plus.

Nolah Evolution Comfort Plus

The Nolah Evolution Comfort Plus is a high-end bed priced at $2,499 for the queen-size model. However, sales and promotion events can drive the price down to as low as $1,624. More importantly, all foams used on this mattress are CertiPUR-US Certified. This means they lack ozone depleters such as formaldehyde, making this mattress safe for people with allergies and asthma.

This Nolah Mattress primarily targets heavyweight sleepers. The queen-size model can accommodate body weights of up to 1,000 pounds. This is thanks to its individually wrapped coils and sturdy foams which are designed to grant heavyweight sleepers excellent body contouring comfort and targeted support. And with a rating of 7.0/10 on the firmness scale, this bed identifies as a firmer mattress. Thanks to its plush pillow top and zoned construction, it provides overweight back and side sleepers the targeted support they need for optimal sleep comfort. For extra strength and stability, the mattress uses AirFoam HD and individually pocketed coils that are thicker than those used in the Nolah Evolution 15” Mattress. Nolah Evolution Comfort Plus is among the few models that stand out with higher performance scores, surpassing average beds in durability, strength, and quality. That's why it comes with a hefty price tag. But if you're willing to dig deeper into your pockets for this one-of-a-kind masterpiece, you can bet it'll be worth the price. 

Similar to other high-end mattresses sold online, Nolah Comfort Plus comes with a lifetime warranty. Moreover, it is backed by a 120-night sleep trial, giving you enough time to test your mattress before deciding whether it suits your needs.

Experiencing Problems with Your Sealy Mattress? 

Sealy is a very reputable and popular mattress company. Though it's well-known for producing quality mattresses, some sleepers may find them unfit for their body weight and sleep position. If you're experiencing issues with your Sealy Mattress, try reaching out to their customer service team. Feel free to call them at their telephone number (800) 499-1988) or email them at consumersupport@sealy.com. Fortunately, they are also available on various social media platforms like X and Facebook–which should make them relatively easily accessible.